Variable speed drives in the dairy shed
For oil vane and blower vacuum pumps
Vacuum pumps are used to produce sufficient air flow to operate the milk harvesting equipment. Vacuum pumps represent approximately 80 percent of energy used by the milking equipment components (Dairying for Tomorrow Info Sheet B2). The other two components, the milk pump and feed motors represent the remaining ten percent respectively. Installing a variable speed drive on a vacuum pump will match the speed of vacuum pumps with the demand for air flow thereby lowering energy consumption and energy emissions, as well as noise in the dairy shed.
A variable speed drive (VSD) will produce the minimum reserve requirement only when there is extra demand for air flow, above what is required for operating the equipment. Energy savings will occur when there is no demand for the extra air flow.
Variable speed drives can be attached to new or existing vacuum pumps. Two commonly used vacuum pumps are oil vane and blower vacuum pumps.
Oil vane vacuum pumps need to operate at high revolutions to provide sufficient vacuum. In some cases they might not be suited to a VSD if the revolutions can not be lowered without wearing out the pump.
Blower vacuum pumps are more energy efficient than oil vane pumps but have a higher initial cost. Blower vacuum pumps are better suited to VSD as they can operate at lower revolutions than oil vane vacuum pumps whilst still maintaining sufficient vacuum. They generally run quieter and have a longer life.
Factors to consider
Some of the considerations for installing a Variable Speed Drive include:
Existing pump – the working condition of the existing pump can influence the potential savings, particularly older pumps.
Pump running time – the size of the dairy relative to the number of cows milked influences potential savings. The greatest gains can be made on longer running times.
Matching pump size with shed size – if the size of the pump is not matched to the dairy shed is money can be saved by upgrading the pump and installing a variable speed drive.
Correct installation and machine testing – full energy saving gains will be achieved when filter protections and components are properly installed and tested.
Dairy shed power type – single phase power may require a larger drive or inverter therefore drawing more power to run. Three phase power may be a better option.
Air consumption – different vacuum pumps with the same motor size (kW) can have different air consumption due to the layout of the system. Leakage of air in the system by incorrect installation can also reduce efficiency.
Motor speed of existing pump – or revolutions per minute (RPM). Greater energy savings are possible where the pump can operate at a lower RPM (e.g. half capacity), for example a 1,400 RPM motor that can be geared down to 700 RPM will benefit from installing a VSD.
Note that the lower motor speed must remain above minimum operating requirement of the motor to avoid unnecessary wear and early replacement.
The energy savings
|Demand for air flow in a vacuum pump|
|Litres of air flow||kWh|
|Total capacity of the vacuum pump (air flow)||2,200||7.5|
|Minimum reserve requirement (AMMTA)*||1,200||3.5|
|Operating equipment (milking & washing)||1,00||4.0|
|Energy savings by installing a VSD||47% (3.5/7.5)|
There are opportunities to reduce energy consumption on vacuum pumps as they typically operate at a constant speed regardless of the demand for air flow. The pump produces sufficient air flow to operate the milk harvesting equipment plus a minimum reserve requirement. When the minimum reserve requirement is not produced there is a 47 percent saving in energy (Table 1).
|Existing pumps||New pumps|
|VSD on existing oil vane pump||VSD on existing blower pump||VSD on new oil vane pump||VSD on new blower pump|
|Net present value (at 7% discount rate, 3% inflation on cash flows)||$10,336||$18,789||-$833||$2,102|
|Internal rate of return (real)||34%||51%||6%||9%|
|Years to breakeven (before interest and tax)||4 years||3 years||>10 years*||10 years|
The new oil vane vacuum pump with a VSD installed did not recoup costs by the end of year ten.
Business as usual option
The hypothetical case study farm has a 7.5 kW oil vane vacuum pump which generates 7.5 kWh per hour. The pump operates for 2.5 hours per milking, with the first hour of weekdays on off-peak time. The pump used 13,650 kWh and cost $2,535 in the first year.
Do they pay?
The most profitable option was installing a Variable Speed Drive (VSD) kit on an existing blower vacuum pump. However a VSD is profitable on any existing vacuum pump.
New blower vacuum pumps were profitable investments whereas a new oil vane vacuum pump would not recoup the initial costs by the end of year ten. The energy savings in the new oil vane vacuum pump did not cover the capital and operating costs over the ten year period.
This suggests that a blower vacuum pump with a VSD installed is the preferred type of pump to replace an existing pump.